Here at the Strategist, we prefer to think about ourselves as crazy (into the way that is good about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing ones. (it is possible to find out about our score system and exactly how we pick each product here.)
Even though we’ve written about a lot of small appliances — including the toaster ovens that are best, top stand mixers, as well as the best most expensive toaster — here, we’ve rounded up top toasters, as praised by the absolute most enthusiastic reviewers on Amazon.
KitchenAid Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever
“Now this will be a toaster,” one reviewer writes. “It is built as solid as a 1957 Buick and looks as razor-sharp. Toasts the hell out of my toast on the setting that is highest.” While dozens of reviewers are impressed by the overall quality of this toaster, there are a few standout features, chief among them the lever that is high-lift. In accordance with one reviewer, the“allows that are high-lift to pull up on the levers to raise the bread high enough to get hold of it.” Reviewers are also pleased with this toaster’s ability to tackle bagels, both because it has a bagel that is specific also wide slots. One reviewer writes, “The slots are wide sufficient for Texas toast and bagels i prefer having two controllers that are separate the desired crispness of the toast.” Reviewers think cleanup is also simple, because “The individual trays that are crumb each end are superb.”
- $60 at Amazon
- Best-rated (more affordable) toaster
Proctor Silex Extra-Wide Slot Toaster with Cool Wall
A few reviewers call this toaster “basic” but they, like numerous others, like it for its easy design. “There’s actually you should not get an elaborate, expensive toaster if all that’s necessary is to toast a bit of bread or a bagel and have now it done correctly,” one writes. And many reviewers reference how evenly this toaster toasts. “This toaster browns the bread perfectly on BOTH sides at once,” one writes, while another says, “Gives a browning that is good on a number of breads and bagels.” Reviewers also love this to be compact. “Its just perfect for a area that is small” one writes. Another who got it for their RV states they “love it” for toasting traveling.
- $15 at Amazon
- Now for some micro-picks for every toaster you might be looking for.
- Best toaster with numerous settings
- Cuisinart Compact Stainless 4-Slice Toaster
- 4.2 stars, 658 reviews
For one user, this toaster means they can stop playing the “‘what’s my toast going to be like today’ game,” and they appreciate that “the bread goes all the way in and gets toasted evenly.” Dozens of reviewers are also impressed by this toaster’s settings that are many. “The warm switch really does just warm your toast,” one writes, while another says, “I utilize the defrost function, and that seems to really make a difference.” One even says that defrost feature means, “I don’t have to wait for things to thaw out, it cooks frozen bread to perfection.” While this is a four-slice toaster, reviewers also appreciate that the controls are separate for both relative sides, which spared at least one marriage. “My favorite part is the fact that you can toast at different levels per side,” one reviewer writes. “Now I don’t have to focus on burning my toast because my husband cranked the dial all the way up. He’s got his part, and I have mine.”
$44 at Amazon